M&S may be removed from FTSE 100
The end of an era is looming for Marks and Spencer, with the retail giant expected to be relegated from the FTSE 100 index of Britain’s biggest listed companies on Wednesday.
If it is demoted, it will be the first time M&S has not been a FTSE 100 member since the index was launched in 1984. The food and fashion giant has had a hard year, with its shares down 40%.
Its all-important clothing business has continued to struggle, and its food business has shown signs of weakness.
“Symbolically, falling out of the FTSE is just another milestone in the slow-but-steady decline of what used to be a great British institution,” says retail expert Richard Hyman.
The FTSE 100 contains the 100 largest UK-listed firms, ranked by market value. Membership of the index is seen as a mark of prestige.
The index is reshuffled four times a year, allowing a handful of companies to enter, while a number of stragglers slip out into the lower tier FTSE 250.
M&S has been close to relegation for a while as investors have steadily lost faith in the brand and it is almost certain to be demoted on Wednesday, bar some large market moves.
As of Tuesday morning, the retailer had a market value of £3.6bn – less than half of what it was worth back in November 2015.
By comparison FTSE-listed fashion rival Next is worth £7.9bn. Demotion would be a huge fall from grace for M&S, which in 1998 became the first British retailer to make a pre-tax profit of more than £1bn.
The biggest issue, say analysts, has been the decline of its clothing business, which accounts for a large portion of profits.
“There has been a decade-long complaint by investors and customers that it has failed to revamp its clothing lines, especially within womenswear, and lacks appeal for the younger generations,” says Helal Miah, an analyst at the Share Centre.
“The group has also been too slow to adapt to online retailing and has been left behind by others who offer a more compelling online service.”
M&S now faces enormous competition from fashion giants such as Primark on the High Street and Asos online. Accusations that its clothing is too dowdy and conservative still linger, too.
However, for Richard Hyman the issue goes deeper – he thinks the brand has lost touch with its customers.
“M&S was about quality at an unbeatable price, not fashion for fashion’s sake. But over time they have sacrificed those values to try and cut costs and become too corporate.”
This has created a “negative spiral”, he says, where less is invested in its product, quality falls, and design goes by the wayside.
“Your sales keep falling so you cut costs further. It is very hard to get out of.”
Until recently, M&S’s food business had been a bright spot amid the gloom, but over the past few years sales in this part of the business have struggled as well.
To stem the decline, in February this year M&S forged a joint venture with Ocado, agreeing to buy 50% of its retail business for a whopping £750m.
Laith Khalaf, an analyst at Hargreaves Lansdown, says the deal makes sense in many ways, as it will allow M&S to offer a much broader range of food. Online shopping is also a growth area.
However, he says investors have been sceptical about the partnership and many think M&S has overpaid.
“Ocado is not yet making a profit from food sales so the rewards of this partnership are uncertain.
“It’s also a new kind of partnership which comes with risks attached. There is a risk that by going to Ocado, M&S could send customers to Waitrose, which also works with Ocado.”
On top of these problems, M&S is dealing with a nationwide consumer spending slowdown that has forced some High Street retailers to close stores.
To try to revive the business, chief executive Stuart Rowe launched a “radical” turnaround plan last year which will see 100 under-performing stores closed by 2022 – although the number could be higher.
However, analysts are sceptical that this will be enough to get it back on track.
“I think it is possible but unfortunately a lot of things are outside of their control,” says Mr Khalaf.
“One of those is the UK economy and all the uncertainty about Brexit, which has also been big factor in denting the share price.
“If there is a further fall in the pound [because of Brexit] that could hit retailers as they buy many imported goods in dollars. A wider downturn in the economy could also hit M&S.”
Mr Hyman also has his doubts about the strategy.
“M&S used to be the pivotal player on the high street but they are going down the wrong road in my opinion. When you see a business which is more about cutting costs than driving sales the alarm bells should be ringing.”